Impose costs to cut frivolous litigation: CJI-designate UU Lalit


NEW DELHI: Reiterating that the justice delivery system is stretched beyond its limits, Chief Justice-designate Uday Umesh Lalit has said that time has come to devise a mechanism to mandatorily impose costs on litigants bringing frivolous cases to courts and putting additional weight on an already burdened judiciary.
“We must devise a mechanism by which courts should mandatorily impose cost on litigants bringing frivolous cases to the courts. The losing side in a frivolous case must be saddled with the cost of using up precious judicial time and resources,” said Justice Lalit, who will take oath as the 49th Chief Justice on August 27.
He added said the primary function of the Supreme Court, as mandated by the Constitution, is to lay down law and decide intricate constitutional issues.

Desi

“If the Supreme Court, even when it had seven or eight judges, could spare five to set up a constitution court, today with a strength of 34 judges, we can surely set up a permanent five-judge bench for that purpose,” he said.
“In normal circumstances, given the position of the Supreme Court, one constitution bench should be in place permanently. Look at the past judges — Justice V Krishna Iyer during his seven year tenure had participated in 55 constitution bench judgments; Justice PN Bhagwati in 113 such judgments. I think we can set up a bench of five-judges permanently,” he said.
Amicus Curiae route to reduce frivolous PILs
With the pandemic restricting the physical functioning of the three-tier justice delivery system for almost two years, the pendency of cases registered a substantial increase in the Supreme Court, the high courts and the district judiciary to cross the four crore mark, with one-fourth of them pending for the past five to 20 years.
CJI-designate Justice UU Lalit said every roadblock in delivering speedy justice must be consciously removed. “As the Supreme Court, we must develop a healthy practice or system to weed out avoidable litigation,” he said.
The SC had devised the concept of public interest litigation, unique to India and somewhat similar to class-action suits of western jurisdictions. This was to enable a public spirited person to bring to the court’ s notice violation of fundamental rights of the poor and deprived who do not have the wherewithal to approach the judiciary for redressal of their grievances. But, in the last decade and half, the SC has witnessed chronic PIL litigants rushing to the court with every issue debated in the public at the drop of a hat. The CJI-designate has a potent solution to eradicate the chronic PIL-mania.
“The constitutional courts can devise a system by which the genuine PILs, entertained by the court, would be conducted only by court-appointed amicus curiae, irrespective of the petitioner, ” he suggested. If the SC and the HCs could put in place this system, many PILs would not take birth as this instrument is primarily aimed at garnering publicity for the petitioner.
Elaborating on his suggestion for SC to have a permanent 5-judge Constitution bench, he said, “In normal circumstances, given the position of the Supreme Court, one Constitution bench should be in place permanently. Look at the past judges — Justice V Krishna Iyer during his seven-year tenure had participated in 55 constitution bench judgments; Justice PN Bhagwati in 113 such judgments. I think we can set up a bench of five-judges permanently,” he said.





Source link

Related posts:

Aditya narayan shares beatutiful pics baby shower with wife shweta agarwal
Why sitting mla of tarai in problem after youth bjp workers racing for election ticket
Nagaland civilian killings amplifies calls for afspa repeal all you need to know about the this law
Tourists Flock To Manali And Solanganala To See The Snow As Soon As The Weather Opens, See Photos - ...
Dog neck long like giraffe with only 3 legs weird animals ashas
Jharkhand and bihar police arrested arms supplier gang of naxals bramk
Hiding Lions Attack Wild Pig in Forest Shocking Jungle Video Viral ashas
Team India lost 2nd ODI to South Africa as 5 reasons for India defeat IND vs SA Highlights
Indore: Elders Who Filed Land Grab Case Against Asaram Ashram Are Missing, Police Are Searching - इं...
Shruti Haasan: श्रुति हासन से फैन ने पूछा- आपके कितने ब्रेकअप हुए, अभिनेत्री ने दिया ये मजेदार जवाब
assembly-election-2022-sadabad-constituency-seat-profile-bjp-sp-bsp-congress - Sadabad Assembly: तो ...
Delhi police Narcotics Cell arrested drug smugglers and recovered worth over 20 lakhs heroin
junior engineer caught accepting bribe of 70 thousand rupees anti corruption bureau team arresst je ...
Jharkhand news clash between two groups during idol immersion in Dhanbad internet down in 4 district...
Jharkhand tourist places villagers demand tourist spot status for ghagra waterfalls india best water...
Up Home Guard Recruitment 2022: Will The Candidates Have To Give An Interview To Become A Home Guard...

Leave a Comment